NEW YORK, NY - DECEMBER 31: Mariah Carey performs during the New Year's Eve Countdown at Times Square on December 31, 2016 in New York City. (Photo by Eugene Gologursky/Getty Images for TOSHIBA CORPORATION)

Not sure if you’ve seen Mariah Carey perform “live” in the last few, oh I don’t know, decades or so but she’s definitely lost her touch.

Actually, “lost her touch” is putting kindly. She sounds horrible live. I’m pretty sure she’s lip sync’d her entire career and we just didn’t pick up on it until HD cameras started catching it.

Nonetheless, people still pay a lot of money to watch her “perform” live and it’s during one of those “performances” this story takes place. Carey decided to bring her two adorable kids on stage while performing “Always Be My Baby” and let her 6 year-old daughter help her sing!

I personally think it’s cute… some of the TMZ staff disagree. What do you think?