And all across Bachelor Nation, hearts shattered as everyone’s crush Wells Adams made it Instagram official with his new girlfriend, Modern Family actress Sarah Hyland.
Adams, who appeared on JoJo Fletcher’s season of the show, as well as Bachelor in Paradise, is a fan favorite. People had hoped he might get together with fellow Bachelor alum Danielle Maltby after their flirty encounter on this season of BIP, or perhaps they imagined building a life of their own with the Nashville-based DJ.
However, this Halloween it quickly became clear that neither would be the case. Adams posted a snap featuring the pair donning Stranger Things-inspired looks. Much to fans’ dismay, Wells and Adams and his new boo looked absolutely adorable as Eleven and Dustin.
In case you tried to convince yourself that these two are just friends who happened to have a very carefully coordinated Halloween costume, he later posted this unmistakably couple-y shot.
But don’t worry! While Adams may be off the market, it appears that Ben Higgins, Nick Viall, and plenty of your other Bachelor Nation favorites are still single. Happy hunting!
Lauren Levine is a freelance writer who has contributed to publications and websites including The Charlotte Observer, U.S. News & World Report, American Way magazine, The Huffington Post, Hello Giggles, Bustle, Thrillist, Thought Catalog, and others.