Maker Of Stanley Tumblers Facing Class Action Lawsuit Over Lead Seal
Just as I was thinking my Yeti Tumbler would be the last reusable cup I would ever need to buy, along came the Stanley Quencher tumbler. I still haven’t hopped on the bandwagon. The only Stanley Cup for me currently belongs to the Vegas Golden Knights. I’m hoping it comes back to the Carolina Hurricanes this year. But back to the tumblers. Apparently, they might have a lead problem.
The future of the trendy drinking vessels is looking a bit murky due to some legal troubles. According to USA Today, Stanley is being sued over a seal in the cups. More specifically, a new class action lawsuit claims the company did not disclose the use or presence of lead in its products. The suit was filed earlier this month by a Seattle-based law firm on behalf of two women in California and Nevada. The women, like many Americans, own multiple Stanley Quenchers.
Misled About Lead?
On Stanley’s website, the company writes that it has been transparent about its use of lead and describes how its products are still deemed safe. A few weeks ago the company confirmed the presence of lead by saying, “Rest assured that no lead is present on the surface of any Stanley product that comes into contact with the consumer nor the contents of the product.” In other words, the lead isn’t touching your beverage so, therefore, it isn’t touching you. The only lead in the cup is the vacuum seal dot at the bottom.
While there’s no evidence of the Stanley Quenchers causing any health issues, the customers who initiated the class action suit feel they should have been warned. And what if the cup is dropped and damaged in such a way that the lead does suddenly come into contact with the contents? That point has also been raised in the suit, which the company says it will fight “vigorously.”
What Doesn’t Kill You Makes You Stronger
As a member of Generation X, I might not worry enough about the presence of lead in my life. First of all, I didn’t grow up with these fancy hydration chalices. I drank from a dirty garden hose with a rusty nozzle every summer of my youth. My water tasted metallic and I liked it! And I was surrounded by lead paint. It was on the walls and on my toys. Did you ever put a Matchbox car in your mouth when you were little? Guess what. Lead!
My father loves to tell the story of a family vacation we took when I was a baby. We stayed at an old bed & breakfast somewhere in Quebec. He says the room was equipped with a crib from the 19th Century that he’s certain was made entirely of lead. As a teething infant, I was probably gumming that thing like crazy. But I turned out alright. Mostly.